Wednesday, September 16, 2015

Thoughts on Drafting

After writing a draft and posting it on my blog for my peers to see, I have learned a lot and have gotten more comfortable with my QRG. Below I have written a short analysis of my draft writing journey.
Reneman. "Icon 'Draft'" Feb 24, 2013. Public Domain.
The book Student's Guide really helped me draft a thesis statement for my information. Even though the book was geared towards a traditional college essay format, I felt like I could organize my information into a concise thought after reviewing the pages.

The problem with the guide in Student's Guide was that it was geared towards the traditional college essay. Although our QRG should contain all of the bulleted information provided in Student's Guide, the reading didn't provide advice on how to work with QRGs conventions such as drawing a reader in, short paragraphs, and separation of ideas into headlines. For example, writing paragraphs in PIE format may not be ideal as that leads to long, detailed, complex paragraphs that are not appealing to the type of reader WRGs try to attract.

Reflection:

After reading Morgan and Alyssa's blog posts I realized that we all took away different information from the Student's Guide guide. Morgan and I disagreed on the use of the PIE format, but after reading her analysis I have new insight as how it can be helpful to use to structure paragraphs. Alyssa and I agreed on how QRGs utilize shorter paragraphs in a concise yet informative format.

I need to work on/revise:
1. A better thesis statement/clearer and more inviting intro paragraph.
2. I didn't finish, I need to include the perspective on how the controversy can be handled better and why american readers would be interested in a controversy happening in Tokyo.
2. I need to work on who is more reasonable credible while also making sure I am not repeating too much information. I need to keep my paragraphs concise yet informative, and delve into more specifics about each sides credibility.



3 comments:

  1. I like how you kept the answers to the questions asked short and concise. I'm realizing now that mine's a bit lengthy. I agree about how a lot of the advice given in the book isn't very applicable to QRGs. You're right, since it didn't provide information about how to write a QRG it was a bit difficult to pick and choose what to use and what not to. Nice job on this post!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with you that the Students' Guide is geared toward college essays. I also need to improve my thesis/intro paragraph as well as my conclusion. I always found those the hardest to write!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi,
    From reading your thoughts on the tips for drafting I agree that the PIE structure felt too rigid and constraining for use in a QRG. I find the QRG to be very similar to the blog genre, and a big block of text would deter readers from really good information.

    ReplyDelete